Describe an ethically challenging situation that you experienced in which you spoke up. and one in which you did not speak up. What did you do (or not do), and what was the result in each case? Which

Individual Paper

Criteria

Ratings

Pts

Description of two ethically challenging
situations (one in which student spoke up: one in which student did not speak
up).

20 to >10.0 pts Full
points

Detailed description that
clearly explains both situations, what actions the student took or did not
take, and their feelings.

10 to >0.0 pts
Satisfactory

Response is somewhat vague,
general, and/or lacking in coherence and may be missing 1 of the points to be
covered (identification of 2 situations, actions, and feelings).

Opts No points

No response is provided in
this category.

20 pts

Description of how the moral
philosophies guided your speaking up (or not) in each situation.

40 to >20.0 pts Full
points

Identified and described
moral philosophy (-ies) beyond just listing them. Gave rich, clear and
insightful explanations of how the moral philosophy (-ies) guided speaking up
(or not) in each situation.

20 to >0.0 pts
Satisfactory

Provided explanation but did
not offer much insight or clearly explain how the moral philosophy (-ies)
guided speaking up (or not) in each situation.

Opts No points

No response is provided in
this category.

40 pts

Identification of

situational/organizational
factors that influenced your speaking up (or not) in each situation.

40 to >20.0 pts Full
points

Clearly identified and
described situational, and/or organizational factors that affected speaking
up (or not) in each situation.

20 to >0.0 pts
Satisfactory

Identified factors without an
accompanying explanation. It may not be clear from the description why these
factors played a role.

Opts No points

No response is provided in
this category.

40 pts